Reese's Ice Cream Pie

It's no doubt that my two favorite candies in the World are Reese's Pieces and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. When I saw this Reese's Ice Cream Pie on Facebook (it was one of those viral videos), I knew I had to make it. Making ice cream pie is a good way to get rid of all that leftover Halloween candy too. The chocolate candy that is. This wouldn't really work well with all those hard candies or licorice. The trick to making this pie is having all the ingredients ready and the ice cream slightly melted so that it is easy to fit in the pie. Everything is store bought so the pie comes together pretty easy.

This week, I am posting Halloween recipes on this blog. I have a drink coming and a bunch of fun dessert ideas, so get ready! I went to Wal-Mart this morning and picked up a bunch of sweet items to use to make treats with today. Halloween is my favorite Holiday of the year!

For more easy Halloween recipes be sure to check out Brownie Batter Graveyard Parfaits, Pumpkin Fluff, and Reese’s Ice Cream Pie. 

INGREDIENTS

• 2 pt. vanilla ice cream, softened
• 1 prepared chocolate cookie pie crust
• ½ c. peanut butter, warmed
• 2 c. crushed Reese's
• ½ c. Reese's pieces

How to Make Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie 

1. Spoon 1 pint of softened vanilla ice cream into Oreo crust and spread with a spatula. Drizzle with ¼ cup warm peanut butter and top with a layer of crushed Reese’s (about 1 cup). Freeze until firm, 30 minutes.
2. Top Reese’s layer with the remaining pint of softened vanilla ice cream. Drizzle with remaining peanut butter and top with crushed Reese’s and Reese’s Pieces. 
3. Freeze until firm and sliceable, 1 hour. Top with a layer of crushed Reese's.

Ice Cream Pie Tips: 

Make your own pie crust or use a store bought one! 

Let the ice cream sit out the counter for a few minutes for it to be come soft and more scoopable. Vanilla or Chocolate would be great. Before serving let it sit out for a bit so it’s easier to slice after being frozen. 

Use your favorite candy for toppings. It doesn’t have to be just peanut butter flavor. 

Other Recipes to Try 

Air Fryer Hard Boiled Eggs

Easy Air Fryer Chicken Breasts

Air Fryer Scotch Eggs with Maple Aoili

Air Fryer Baja Fish Tacos with Pickled Onions

Air Fryer Frozen Hash Brown Patties 

Let Me Know What You Think!

Be sure to leave a review of this recipe and give it a star rating. It lets us know how we are doing and lets others know they should try it! 

Are you in Pinterest?  If so upload a recipe photo and share it with me. I love to see what you’re making 

Are you on Instagram? Follow along and tag me @wwrecipediaries.

Have a Question or General Feedback?

Jump down to the COMMENT section and let us know! We would love to help and also love feedback on all of our posts.

This is not a Weight Watcher Recipe

Print

Recipe adapted from Delish.com